“So, I know we have talked, but how are you really doing?” Scott asked.
“You know, work is going well. I’m due for another promotion soon, so that will be nice. And Maggie…well you’ve seen her. She’s getting so big! They grow up so…” Michael stopped himself.
He is doing it again. It all sounds good. It really does. The problem is he does not believe any of it.
For whatever reason, on this night, he stopped himself. Maybe it is because it is Christmas Eve. Maybe it is because he trusts Scott. Perhaps, it is because you can only lie to yourself so many times.
“Truth is, Scott, I’m not doing real well. I mean, I should be doing well. Work is going good, and I know a lot of people here in Atlanta. Maggie is doing well in school, but I don’t know. I feel very alone, and I used to be okay with it….” Michael paused.
“I don’t think I have ever fully recovered from when Annie walked out on us,” Michael said softly, the tone of his voice saying more than the words itself.
“Well, I don’t know if that is something you just recover from. I mean, I’m early in this process, but I don’t know…” Scott began to weep.
The year had been particularly hard for Scott. He was pastoring a large church in North Carolina. The church was growing like crazy. He even had a book deal on the table. They were hoping for a December release.
In June it all changed.
Scott had an affair with another man, and Becky found out. She packed their two kids up and left.
“I never want to see you again. You are a failure. I can’t believe I married such a pervert! As long as I have anything to do with it, you will never have a role in the kid’s life again,” Scott replayed this final scene with his ex-wife over and over again. Always wishing that somehow the scene would change this time, but it never did.
About two weeks after Becky left, the church fired him as the pastor. They added that he was no longer allowed to ever step foot in the church building again.
“You are the kind of person that we preach against! This church cannot afford to have any queers walking around here! You are such a disgrace. Go get your life together,” Scott remembered one of the elders saying to him before he left.
So, here they are. Two old friends spending Christmas Eve at a dive bar. One who appears to have it all together. Another who does not. Neither of them happy, but each trying to make sense of their lives.
“Michael, it’s just that life is harder than we give it credit for sometimes. There isn’t a day that goes by where I don’t wish I could take it all back…The thing is that I can’t. All people care about is what happened…I don’t doubt that if you could trade all of what you have now to get Annie back, you would do it in a second,” Scott said with tears rolling down his face.
“I guess I just would like to have had a conversation, you know? I mean, I thought we loved each other. How can someone just walk out on love? I trusted her, Scott. I really trusted her, and she made me look like a fool. Maybe it would not have been so bad if it was just me but there’s Maggie to think about, too.
Just last week she was asking about her mom. I never know what to say. I try to stay as vague as possible. What kind of five year old is ready to handle the fact that her mom walked out on her?” Michael asked.
So there in a small bar, Michael and Scott were no longer alone. They were surrounded by each other’s questions.
“Michael, I want to tell you the answer is to just not trust people. In fact, I wish that were the right answer. The more I try to run away, the more it seems like we really need people. As if our universe hinged on loving and being loved by others,” Scott said.
“I know this day is a big deal for you, Scott. I mean, it used to be. Here we are on Christmas Eve sitting at a dive bar, crying about our problems,” Michael said with a forced laugh.
“Yea, I dunno, Michael. Maybe I’m starting to wonder about it all. I have my doubts that if Jesus were here, we would find him in the church on Christmas Eve. For one, I don’t think he’d be invited.
I guess I picture Jesus walking away from the closed doors and throwing his own birthday party here. On his way to the party, he rounds up everyone he can find on the street. You know, the ones that didn’t seem fit for church. The ones who have been abandoned and who have abandoned other people.
We’d sing Christmas carols, drink eggnog, and for once, it wouldn’t matter what kind of person you were because we would realize we are all in the same boat.”
So, I guess you could say Michael and Scott pondered these things in their hearts that night.
Some have said that Scott preached his best sermon that night in the tiny little bar in Atlanta. He did not feel like much of a preacher any more, and Michael did not feel much like a successful businessman, either.
Perhaps that is what made the night so beautiful.


